HombreOilsRare perfumery, preserved

The recordsAll teaching accords

Station 8 of 13 · Accord · the record

A muguet (lily of the valley), and what regulation took from it

A muguet composed from synthetic materials, because lily of the valley gives no oil, and a lesson in what regulation removed.

Teaching accord A teaching accord for learning: not a commercial perfume formula, not a finished perfume, not safety-assessed; do not make it for skin.

Two of its classic materials are now prohibited in EU cosmetics. Remove them and see what the heart loses; the substitutions show the usual response.

The record

Each field carries its evidence: open a chip for the source, the quoted words and the confidence. A field with nothing behind it says so and stays empty.

Name
A muguet (lily of the valley), and what regulation took from it
house interpretation

the house’s own reading, labelled as such

the house’s name for this teaching accord

confidence C

Purpose
teaching
house rule

the house’s own reading, labelled as such

the site’s rule: every accord on record is a teaching accord; the house’s own formulas are never published here

confidence B

Structure
A muguet built from aldehydes and alcohols: the flower gives no oil, so the note is composed from synthetic materials.
perfumery convention

the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

the trade’s convention; the Osmothèque classes Diorissimo (1956) as a muguet soliflore ("Solinote Muguet"). Two of the classic materials are now prohibited in EU cosmetics (p-BMHCA, HICC): the accord keeps them to teach the change

confidence B

Family
floral (the Osmothèque’s "Solinote Muguet")
perfumery convention

Diorissimo DIOR 1956 EDT Floral Solinote Muguet Edmond Roudnitska

OSMO-1 · Osmothèque, Conservatoire international des parfums · read 2026-09-30

the family as the Osmothèque classes a fragrance of this structure

confidence B

Components
Under each component, the evidence for its place in the accord. Teaching parts are a house interpretation for learning: modeled, not measured, not a formula.
ComponentRoleTeaching partsVolatility
Hydroxycitronellal
perfumery convention

the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

the trade’s convention; no odour description is filed for it

confidence B

heart
perfumery convention

the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

the trade’s top / heart / base convention for this material

confidence B

40 parts
modeled

modeled

teaching proportions, a house interpretation for learning: modeled, not measured, not a formula, not for making

confidence C

not on record
why

no volatility class on record for hydroxycitronellal

Butylphenyl methylpropional
documented

Lysmeral (2-(4-tert-butylbenzyl)propionaldehyde) is a synthetically produced aliphatic-aromatic aldehyde reminiscent of the smell of lily of the valley.

LIL-1 · Fichter SC, Groth K, Fiedler N, Kolossa-Gehring M, Dębiak M, on behalf of the INGER Study Group · read 2026-09-30

prohibited in EU cosmetic products since 1 March 2022 (eu-2021-1902)

confidence A

heart
perfumery convention

the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

the trade’s top / heart / base convention for this material

confidence B

20 parts
modeled

modeled

teaching proportions, a house interpretation for learning: modeled, not measured, not a formula, not for making

confidence C

not on record
why

no volatility class on record for p-bmhca

Hydroxyisohexyl 3-cyclohexene carboxaldehyde
perfumery convention

the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

prohibited in EU cosmetic products (eu-2017-1410); kept here to teach what was lost

confidence C

heart
perfumery convention

the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

the trade’s top / heart / base convention for this material

confidence B

5 parts
modeled

modeled

teaching proportions, a house interpretation for learning: modeled, not measured, not a formula, not for making

confidence C

not on record
why

no volatility class on record for hicc

2-phenylethyl alcohol
perfumery convention

the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

the trade’s convention

confidence B

heart
documented

Floral notes, such as rose, jasmine, orange blossom, or lavender, are typically middle notes defining the “heart” of many perfumes

KLE-1 · Kleoff et al. (2022). Synthesis of odorants in flow and their applications in perfumery · read 2026-09-30

the review names rose among the floral heart notes

confidence A

20 parts
modeled

modeled

teaching proportions, a house interpretation for learning: modeled, not measured, not a formula, not for making

confidence C

not on record
why

no volatility class on record for phenylethyl-alcohol

Linalool
perfumery convention

the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

the trade’s convention

confidence B

top
perfumery convention

the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

the trade’s top / heart / base convention for this material

confidence B

15 parts
modeled

modeled

teaching proportions, a house interpretation for learning: modeled, not measured, not a formula, not for making

confidence C

top
modeled

modeled

the molecule record’s volatility class (modeled: the house’s volatility table is a set of site constants, not measurements)

confidence C

Substitutions
In history
Fragrances of this family

Causal Debugger why did this change matter?

Teaching accord · modeled A teaching accord for learning: not a commercial perfume formula, not a finished perfume, not safety-assessed; do not make it for skin. Everything below is computed by a teaching model from the records: modeled, not measured, and not a prediction of how any real perfume smells. Regulation lines are flags, not legal advice.

Change one thing and follow it down the chain: the proportions, the molecules, the words on record, a modeled reading, the dry-down, odour activity where a threshold is measured, the regulations, the provenance. Then: why it mattered.

One change

Without JavaScript these controls stay still: every single change is worked out below.

Modeled · before → after

Choose one component and one change: each layer of the chain appears here, labelled modeled, each input with its evidence.

Every single change, worked out without JavaScript: the worked cases.

What the model reads, with its evidence

Hydroxycitronellal
descriptors: not on record · class: heart (role) · threshold: not on record · regulation: IFRA Standard: Hydroxycitronellal (restriction); Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products (a labelling condition (Annex III)) · provenance:
2-phenylethyl alcohol
descriptors: floral, honey
documented
· class: heart (role) · threshold: 140 µg/kg in water
measured
· regulation: none on record · provenance: occurs in rose absolute; occurs in rose otto
linalool
descriptors: sharp, medicinal
house interpretation

the house’s own reading, labelled as such

the record

where the site says it: /materials, “Lavandula angustifolia”

· class: top (volatility, modeled) · threshold: 3.2 ng/L in air
measured
· regulation: Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products (a labelling condition (Annex III)) · provenance: occurs in bergamot essential oil

the model’s input as data: /data/causal/muguet-teaching-accord.json · the model and its formulas: the site’s build

Perfume Autopsy two versions, side by side

Teaching variants · modeled A teaching accord for learning: not a commercial perfume formula, not a finished perfume, not safety-assessed; do not make it for skin. Its versions below are teaching variants of it, not commercial perfume formulas and not the formula of any real perfume. Everything compared is computed by the teaching model the Causal Debugger uses: modeled, not measured, and not a prediction of how anything smells. Regulation lines are flags, not legal advice.

Pick two versions of this accord and see what changed, then what follows from it: the molecules, the words on record, a modeled reading, the dry-down, odour activity where a threshold is measured, the regulations, the provenance. Then: why it could smell different.

The versions, and why each exists

  1. Version 1 · Classic: HICC and p-BMHCA teaching variant, modeled

    Why it exists: the record as written. The muguet as the record writes it, with the two classic materials that EU law now prohibits in cosmetics, kept to teach the change.

    perfumery convention

    the trade’s shared vocabulary; no single source

    the accord record’s structure field (perfumery convention); the prohibitions are on the Regulation records and in versions 2 and 3

    field: this accord’s record · teaching variants · version 1 · why

    confidence B

  2. Version 2 · Without HICC (EU law) teaching variant, modeled

    Why it exists: a regulation on record. EU law (Regulation (EU) 2017/1410) prohibits HICC in cosmetic products placed on the EU market from 23 August 2019. Its parts go to hydroxycitronellal, the record’s own substitution: a house teaching move, and hydroxycitronellal is itself restricted by an IFRA Standard (the industry’s own standard, not law).

    documented

    From 23 August 2019 cosmetic products containing one or more of the substances prohibited by this Regulation shall not be placed on the Union market.

    Commission Regulation (EU) 2017/1410 of 2 August 2017 amending Annexes II and III to Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 · listed on the record

    the prohibition is documented (its Regulation record); the replacement and the parts are the house’s, modeled. US law: not on record

    field: this accord’s record · teaching variants · version 2 · why

    confidence A

  3. Version 3 · Without HICC or p-BMHCA (EU law) teaching variant, modeled

    Why it exists: a regulation on record. EU law (Regulation (EU) 2021/1902) prohibits butylphenyl methylpropional (p-BMHCA) in cosmetic products, applying from 1 March 2022. With HICC already gone, both parts go to hydroxycitronellal, the record’s substitution: a house teaching move.

    documented

    It shall apply from 1 March 2022.

    Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/1902 of 29 October 2021 amending Annexes II, III and V to Regulation (EC) No… · listed on the record

    the prohibition is documented (its Regulation record, Annex II entry 1666); the replacement and the parts are the house’s, modeled. US law: not on record

    field: this accord’s record · teaching variants · version 3 · why

    confidence A

Each version in teaching parts (modeled; each version adds up to 100 parts; a dash: not in that version)
ComponentV1V2V3
Hydroxycitronellal404565
butylphenyl methylpropional2020not in this version
HICC5not in this versionnot in this version
2-phenylethyl alcohol202020
linalool151515

With JavaScript, any two of the 3 versions can be compared.

Modeled · A → B

Pick two versions above to compare them. Version 1 against version 2, worked out without JavaScript: the worked comparison.

the comparison’s input as data: the versions of this accord (JSON) · the model, as code, built on the Causal Debugger’s model

Sources

  1. OSMO-1 · Osmothèque, Conservatoire international des parfums. Collection Osmothèque, juin 2015 (PDF list: name, house, launch year, concentration, family, sub-family, perfumers). www.osmotheque.fr/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Col… · read 2026-09-30 · no reuse licence stated; short quotes and single facts only, under fair use (quoted, not reproduced)
  2. KLE-1 · Kleoff M, Kiler P, Heretsch P. Synthesis of odorants in flow and their applications in perfumery. Beilstein J Org Chem. 2022;18:754–768. doi.org/10.3762/bjoc.18.76 · read 2026-09-30 · CC BY 4.0
  3. LIL-1 · Fichter SC, Groth K, Fiedler N, Kolossa-Gehring M, Dębiak M, on behalf of the INGER Study Group. Lysmeral Exposure in Children and Adolescences Participating in the German Environmental Survey (2012-2015): Integrating Sex/Gender into Analysis. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022;19(24):17072. DOI 10.3390/ijerph192417072. PMID 36554956. PMCID PMC9778794. doi.org/10.3390/ijerph192417072 · read 2026-09-30 · CC BY 4.0

Our text and structure are CC BY 4.0; quoted source text stays under its owners’ terms.

this record as data: /data/accord/muguet-teaching-accord.json · version 4 · updated 2026-10-01 · confidence B